Ellen Pupeter

Towards a “New Cultural World Order”? Decolonization and the Restitution of Cultural Property, ca. 1970-1990

The dissertation project examines the debates on the possible restitution of cultural objects to their countries of origin as part of decolonization and North-South relations between the late 1960s and 1980s.

Following independence, numerous states in Africa and Asia demanded the return of art and cultural objects that had been translocated to the countries of the Global North during the colonial era. From the 1970s onwards, the issue of restitution was discussed at the United Nations and UNESCO with reference to the concept of a “new cultural world order”. At the same time, bilateral negotiations took place on the restitution of individual objects from mostly ethnological museum collections. Demands by countries of the Global South were not only directed against the last Europe’s last colonial powers in Europe, but also affected the Federal Republic and the GDR. Both German states had large stocks of non-European art and cultural assets as a result of earlier collecting activities in the colonies and within colonial networks. Accordingly, stakeholders on both sides of the border were intensively engaged with the question of restitution, albeit under different conditions.

The project examines the emergence and development of the debate on postcolonial cultural restitution at the intersections of international organisations, bilateral negotiations, foreign and national cultural policy and museums. In doing so, it seeks to demonstrate to what extent different negotiating spaces and actors as well as interpretations of the colonial past and political allegiances influenced attitudes toward restitution.

---

Publications

Pupeter, Ellen: Eine Frage der Glaubwürdigkeit? Postkoloniale Restitution und DDR-Kulturpolitik in den 1970er und 1980er Jahren, in: Zeitgeschichte-online, März 2020, URL: https://zeitgeschichte-online.de/node/58121.

Ellen Pupeter, Restitution, Rückgabe oder Transfer? Ein langer Streit um den passenden Begriff, in: Zeitgeschichte-online: Dossier Restitution und Postkolonialismus. Zeitgeschichtliche Perspektiven auf die Debatten der Gegenwart, Februar 2021, URL: https://zeitgeschichte-online.de/themen/restitution-rueckgabe-oder-transfer.

Kontroverse Institutionen. Deutungskämpfe in und um Museen, Sektionsbericht Historikertag 2021 vom 12.11.21, URL: https://www.hsozkult.de/conferencereport/id/tagungsberichte-9141

Lectures

Restitution und Dekolonisierung 1973-2021, Ringvorlesung Akteure der Denkmalpflege. Berichte aus der Praxis am Lehrstuhl für Denkmalpflege/ Heritage Sciences der Otto-Friedrich-Universität Bamberg, 18.05.2021.

Die Kunst der Anderen. Die Bundesrepublik, die DDR und die postkoloniale Kulturgutrestitution im Kalten Krieg, 30. Brown Bag Breakfast im Berliner Kolleg Kalter Krieg/ Berlin Center for Cold War Studies, 06.05.2021.

Eine „neue kulturelle Weltordnung“? Dekolonisierung und Restitution von Kulturgütern in den 1970er und 1980er Jahren, Doktorand*innen-Kolloquium am Leibniz Zentrum für Zeithistorische Forschung Potsdam, 04.02.2021.

„Die Restitutionspolitik der DDR“, Interview vom 01.08.22 für Art in Networks – The GDR and its Global Relations, URL:https://artinnetworks.webspace.tu-dresden.de/de/beitraege/die-restitutionspolitik-der-ddr